Ordered strap in Oxblood with black stitching. Arrived USPS within 5ish days, (two of which were the weekend). Quality seems really nice. The leather is a little thinner that I was imagining, but it seems sturdy and gives the strap a really nice, comfy elasticity. Color is almost exactly as shown, which is a relief.
Piece of advice: ORDER FROM THE JACK FOSTER WEBSITE. Seller's personal site has a few more options such as the finish on the hardware, (I wish I knew I could specified polished instead of brushed), and strap length, (I'm on the very last buckle hole with my tiny 6.5" wrists).
Regardless, Jack Foster is offering a good strap at a good price and I'm excited to wear such a comfortable, hand-made, American product.